Choosing between a new vs used ATV comes down to what you can afford to fix, not only what you can afford to buy. A used machine can save thousands, but only if it passes a careful inspection.
If you are still at the start of your search, our guide on how to buy an atv gives the wider picture first.
| Repair item | Typical cost |
|---|---|
| Replacement tire set, with mounting | Upward of $480 |
| Ball joint, installed | $140 per side |
| Shock, installed | $150 each |
| CV joint, installed | $250 each |
| Complete brake job | About $175 |
| Chain and sprocket set, parts and labor | About $300 |
These figures come from Family Handyman’s used ATV buying guide, which was updated on Sep. 25, 2024. Prices change and vary by region and workshop, so check the source before you rely on them.
What a used ATV can save you
The main argument for buying used is price. Family Handyman’s guide says a used ATV can save you thousands over the price of a new model, as shown on its buying guide page. It adds a warning: a low price is a good price only if the entire rig checks out.
That warning is the whole trade-off. A new machine costs more up front, but it starts without a history of rough use, skipped servicing or hidden damage. A used one passes that risk to you, so the saving is only real once you subtract the repairs it needs.
Which wear items can erase the savings?
Start with the tires. According to the guide, ATV tires age and crack like car tires, and cracked ones are dangerous to ride on. If one is cracked and all of them show the same wear, plan on a full set, which can easily cost upward of $480 with mounting labor.
Next come the ball joints, wheel bearings and shocks. Sloppy steering and instability in turns are warning signs of worn bearings and joints. The same source puts ball joints at $140 per side installed, with wheel bearings costing about the same, and shocks at $150 each installed.

The drivetrain is the next place to look. CV boots keep grease in the rotating joint, and a torn boot lets in water and sand. The guide says to check all eight joints, and it lists new boots at $150 each to install and new CV joints at $250 each installed, per the Family Handyman page.
Then check the brakes. A new pad is about 1/4 in. thick, and a used one can still be above the 1/16 in. minimum while being close to the point where a rotor is at risk. Rotors are almost $120 each and a complete brake job is about $175, according to the same guide.
Finally, look at the engine and final drive. Oil leaks from the valve cover and head gaskets can cost $150 and $300, and a chain and sprocket set is about $300 for parts and labor, as the guide reports.
Red flags that should end the deal
Some findings are worth more than a haggling point. The guide treats these as reasons to step back:
- Metallic particles in the engine or transmission oil: the guide says not to buy the machine.
- Signs of mice or other rodents living in the air cleaner housing: walk away.
- Large accumulations of dirt under the air cleaner cover, which point to poor maintenance.
- Fresh oil on a rag wiped around the head and valve cover gaskets.
- Play when you rock a jacked-up wheel in and out.
Our separate checklist on what to check when buying a used atv goes through the inspection in more detail.
When does buying new make more sense?
The sources here cover used machines only, so they cannot price the new side of the comparison. What they do show is how much of a used purchase depends on inspection. If any of the following describes you, a new machine may suit you better:
- You cannot inspect a used machine yourself and have no mechanic you trust to do it.
- You would rather not keep a repair budget set aside after buying.
- You want a known service history from day one.
Whichever way you lean, the drive layout matters as well, and our comparison of 4×4 vs 2wd atv models explains that choice. Registration, insurance and local riding rules differ by place, so ask the relevant authority or a qualified professional rather than relying on a general guide.
Frequently asked questions
Is a used ATV always the cheaper choice?
Show answer
No. A cheap listing can hide worn tires, joints and brakes, and those bills stack up quickly. Compare the asking price plus likely repairs with a new price, not the sticker alone.
Should a mechanic look at a used ATV before I buy?
Show answer
Family Handyman built its checklist with a powersports shop owner, which shows that much of the inspection is mechanical work. If you are not confident doing it, a qualified mechanic can look the machine over for you.
What does metal in the oil mean?
Show answer
The guide’s advice is blunt: if you see metallic particles in the oil, do not buy the machine. Treat it as a deal-breaker rather than a bargaining point.
How can I spot a worn wheel bearing or ball joint?
Show answer
Jack up one side and rock the tire in and out. Any play points to a bad bearing, a bad ball joint or both, and the other side is likely close behind.



